Block AutoBone with high error values #614

New Issue

MrUnknownDE · 2026-04-05T20:18:52+02:00

MrUnknownDE commented

2026-04-05 20:18:52 +02:00

Originally created by @ButterscotchV on 9/28/2024

Reasonable error values should be around 0.01, though this is not always the case. I've set the max value to 0.03 which should more than cover the 99% SD for the 26 decent recordings I had. Also we never use the "actual height" thingy on the GUI so please just get rid of it lol, people get confused about it and play with it expecting it to magic their height to be better but it does literally nothing. I also fixed a couple other smol things related to AutoBone.

If a user really wants to go ahead with a bad result, they can change the new config maxFinalError and then idk become a giraffe or smth.

This needs to be expanded to have a proper GUI implementation as per #1148. Currently it just says AutoBone has had an error and that's not particularly helpful. Ideally, this should never happen if the user hasn't messed something up, so even if we can't quite tell the user properly yet, we should prevent it.

Experiments

29 recordings from different people and hardcoding a height of 1.5m

All recordings

0.043686678 (SD 0.128893488)

Reasonable recordings (filtered outliers, 26 recordings)

0.012765342 (SD 0.005549119)

Per-recording

Per-recording data (long)

0.008044279 (SD 0.0057397415)
0.009722101 (SD 0.007074401)
0.015543836 (SD 0.010885314)
0.014618757 (SD 0.009086363)
0.009230162 (SD 0.0056077885)
0.009911836 (SD 0.0057559223)
0.009756888 (SD 0.0061521004)
0.011781562 (SD 0.007694296)
0.012112306 (SD 0.008847282)
0.010388792 (SD 0.008162508)
0.010495536 (SD 0.0074977623)
0.010657617 (SD 0.006366505)
0.008758609 (SD 0.0051170522)
0.024134938 (SD 0.010787795)
0.019134283 (SD 0.012941342)
0.016917534 (SD 0.009113287)
0.062933 (SD 0.035469808)
0.7079585 (SD 0.14270139)
0.013365535 (SD 0.010532115)
0.006882551 (SD 0.004092141)
0.009488388 (SD 0.0062766294)
0.021189123 (SD 0.008023828)
0.031142853 (SD 0.03875999)
0.010448145 (SD 0.0082971575)
0.16412327 (SD 0.10965322)
0.009217768 (SD 0.00449746)
0.009072132 (SD 0.0046666353)
0.0117462985 (SD 0.008824699)
0.008137071 (SD 0.006440156)

*Originally created by @ButterscotchV on 9/28/2024* Reasonable error values should be around 0.01, though this is not always the case. I've set the max value to 0.03 which should more than cover the 99% SD for the 26 decent recordings I had. Also we never use the "actual height" thingy on the GUI so please just get rid of it lol, people get confused about it and play with it expecting it to magic their height to be better but it does literally nothing. I also fixed a couple other smol things related to AutoBone. If a user *really* wants to go ahead with a bad result, they can change the new config `maxFinalError` and then idk become a giraffe or smth. This needs to be expanded to have a proper GUI implementation as per #1148. Currently it just says AutoBone has had an error and that's not particularly helpful. Ideally, this should *never* happen if the user hasn't messed something up, so even if we can't quite tell the user properly yet, we should prevent it. ## Experiments 29 recordings from different people and hardcoding a height of 1.5m ### All recordings 0.043686678 (SD 0.128893488) ### Reasonable recordings (filtered outliers, 26 recordings) 0.012765342 (SD 0.005549119) ### Per-recording <details> <summary>Per-recording data (long)</summary> 0.008044279 (SD 0.0057397415) 0.009722101 (SD 0.007074401) 0.015543836 (SD 0.010885314) 0.014618757 (SD 0.009086363) 0.009230162 (SD 0.0056077885) 0.009911836 (SD 0.0057559223) 0.009756888 (SD 0.0061521004) 0.011781562 (SD 0.007694296) 0.012112306 (SD 0.008847282) 0.010388792 (SD 0.008162508) 0.010495536 (SD 0.0074977623) 0.010657617 (SD 0.006366505) 0.008758609 (SD 0.0051170522) 0.024134938 (SD 0.010787795) 0.019134283 (SD 0.012941342) 0.016917534 (SD 0.009113287) 0.062933 (SD 0.035469808) 0.7079585 (SD 0.14270139) 0.013365535 (SD 0.010532115) 0.006882551 (SD 0.004092141) 0.009488388 (SD 0.0062766294) 0.021189123 (SD 0.008023828) 0.031142853 (SD 0.03875999) 0.010448145 (SD 0.0082971575) 0.16412327 (SD 0.10965322) 0.009217768 (SD 0.00449746) 0.009072132 (SD 0.0046666353) 0.0117462985 (SD 0.008824699) 0.008137071 (SD 0.006440156) </details>

MrUnknownDE closed this issue

2026-04-05 20:18:52 +02:00

Sign in to join this conversation.

Branches Tags

main

sapphire/diy-fw-tool-version-sort

aed/grammar-police

battery-0

bscotch/server-rewrite-temp

hannah/steam

pontoon

hannah/keybinds

server-rewrite

bscotch/accel-mount

dependabot/github_actions/gradle/actions-6

dependabot/github_actions/pnpm/action-setup-5

dependabot/github_actions/actions/upload-artifact-7

dependabot/github_actions/actions/download-artifact-8

FloorClipSteamLinkInteractionFix

sapphire/trim-vrm-json

llelievr/trackers-udp-tests

sapphire/linux-bridge-kotlin

sapphire/linux-vrchat-compatdata-path

smol-sleep-state

sapphire/stay-aligned-setup-no-step-skip

sapphire/steamvr-hands-warning

sapphire/proportions-import-skeleton-request

sapphire/bone-mask-update

llelievr/settings-profiles

bscotch/proguard

bscotch/bvh-fix

mitten

bscotch/reset-proof-tests

hannah/install-from-server

smol-buttons

TheButlah-patch-1

sapphire/update-solarxr

sapphire/kotlin-flatbuffers

csv-data-export

feat_flashmode

bscotch/remove-drift-compensation

llelievr/kotlin-config

bscotch/fix-osc-duplication

llelievr/keep-battery-value

rest-calibration-support

tracker-graph

fingertracking

update-eslint

tauri-android

hide-new-resets

height-config

snap-serial

feat/new-updater

support-inches

vrc-fix-ik-key

llelievr/3dmodel-preview

accel-mapping-fixes

llelievr/manual-proportions-rework

llelievr/put-automatic-steamvr-tracker-assigment-first

llelievr/remove-manual-mounting-onboarding

onboarding-usage-step

oldflex

motion-compensation

kotlin-warnings-fix

accessories

tpose

foxvr

No Label Area: AutoBone Area: AutoBone Area: AutoBone Area: AutoBone Area: AutoBone Area: AutoBone Area: AutoBone Area: AutoBone Area: AutoBone Area: AutoBone Area: AutoBone Area: AutoBone Area: AutoBone Area: AutoBone Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: GUI Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Area: Server Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Priority: High Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement Type: Enhancement

1 Participants

Notifications

Due Date

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: github/SlimeVR-Server#614